Opens in a new tab

A literature review of the social performance of carbon-offsetting projects with special reference to Indigenous participation

Resource Key: KQA48C38

Document Type: Report

Creator:

Author:

  • John Burton
  • Julia Keenan
  • Centre for Social Responsibility in Mining

Creators Name:

Place: Queensland

Institution: The University of Queensland

Date: July 2024

Language: en

This desktop review examines the social performance of carbon-offsetting projects in the Global South with the objective of informing the design of an Indigenous-led carbon project based on the conservation of the Alto Mayo Awajún forests in the Peruvian Amazon as proposed by the FERIAAM, the Federacion Regional Indigena Awajun del Alto Mayo, and Conservational International. In this review, we adopt the methodology of selecting projects from international databases and registries that meet the following four criteria: (a) projects must be in regions of the Global South and based on the conservation or restoration of natural environments, (b) projects must be founded on community consultation and participation in decision-making, (c) project zones must include the ancestral lands of Indigenous people, and (d) evidence of poverty reduction and contributions to sustainable development must be a reporting requirement. Part I of the review gives a thumbnail sketch of carbon-offsetting schemes, with a focus on the voluntary schemes that have proliferated since the turn of the millennium. Four schemes are identified that place an emphasis on social performance, termed “enhanced schemes”. Part II examines projects in the enhanced schemes. Applying the four criteria reduces the approximately 4000 projects in the schemes to seventeen cases. A traffic light system is used to summarise how well each project fares against best practice, together with a rating on Arnstein’s Ladder of Participation. Part III draws advice for good practice from the cases in the form of eight lessons learned and makes suggestions for the Awajún carbon project. Our review has obvious limitations. Governmental carbon policies are well-known to constrain the operation of carbon projects within national jurisdictions, to the extent of periodically imposing moratoriums, but we do not enter this complex area. Equally, it is certain that we greatly simplify the socio-political contexts of all the projects that we refer to. However, the most serious limitation is what we can learn about the projects through their formal validation, verification, and/or monitoring reports. The reports describe project results against matrices of indicators and thus measure outputs, but are weak on reporting outcomes, failing to detect an egregious scandal in the worst case. Fortunately, researchers from academic institutions, civil society organisations, and independent review panels provide additional information that we have been able to draw upon. The four schemes do prioritise the involvement of community participants in decision-making, but only one (in CCB Community Gold project) asks project to be “community-led”, and it is only as one of two options. This has forced us to take a wider view of what an Indigenous-led project might look like. We found five projects where predominantly Indigenous communities had significant degrees of control, even if co-management arrangements were in place with NGOs. Finally, after reviewing our draft report, our Landesa colleagues requested further detail on some matters, and we respond to these in an extra appendix.

Download Document

A literature review of the social performance of carbon-offsetting projects with special reference to Indigenous participation

Resource Key: KQA48C38

Document Type: Report

Creator:

Author:

  • John Burton
  • Julia Keenan
  • Centre for Social Responsibility in Mining

Creators Name: {mb_resource_zotero_creatorsname}

Place: Queensland

Institution: The University of Queensland

Date: July 2024

Language: en

This desktop review examines the social performance of carbon-offsetting projects in the Global South with the objective of informing the design of an Indigenous-led carbon project based on the conservation of the Alto Mayo Awajún forests in the Peruvian Amazon as proposed by the FERIAAM, the Federacion Regional Indigena Awajun del Alto Mayo, and Conservational International. In this review, we adopt the methodology of selecting projects from international databases and registries that meet the following four criteria: (a) projects must be in regions of the Global South and based on the conservation or restoration of natural environments, (b) projects must be founded on community consultation and participation in decision-making, (c) project zones must include the ancestral lands of Indigenous people, and (d) evidence of poverty reduction and contributions to sustainable development must be a reporting requirement. Part I of the review gives a thumbnail sketch of carbon-offsetting schemes, with a focus on the voluntary schemes that have proliferated since the turn of the millennium. Four schemes are identified that place an emphasis on social performance, termed “enhanced schemes”. Part II examines projects in the enhanced schemes. Applying the four criteria reduces the approximately 4000 projects in the schemes to seventeen cases. A traffic light system is used to summarise how well each project fares against best practice, together with a rating on Arnstein’s Ladder of Participation. Part III draws advice for good practice from the cases in the form of eight lessons learned and makes suggestions for the Awajún carbon project. Our review has obvious limitations. Governmental carbon policies are well-known to constrain the operation of carbon projects within national jurisdictions, to the extent of periodically imposing moratoriums, but we do not enter this complex area. Equally, it is certain that we greatly simplify the socio-political contexts of all the projects that we refer to. However, the most serious limitation is what we can learn about the projects through their formal validation, verification, and/or monitoring reports. The reports describe project results against matrices of indicators and thus measure outputs, but are weak on reporting outcomes, failing to detect an egregious scandal in the worst case. Fortunately, researchers from academic institutions, civil society organisations, and independent review panels provide additional information that we have been able to draw upon. The four schemes do prioritise the involvement of community participants in decision-making, but only one (in CCB Community Gold project) asks project to be “community-led”, and it is only as one of two options. This has forced us to take a wider view of what an Indigenous-led project might look like. We found five projects where predominantly Indigenous communities had significant degrees of control, even if co-management arrangements were in place with NGOs. Finally, after reviewing our draft report, our Landesa colleagues requested further detail on some matters, and we respond to these in an extra appendix.

Download Document