Review of social impact assessment in transport planning practices: Lessons from cities in England
Resource Key: Z4R3G9KQ
Document Type: Journal Article
Creator:
Creators Name:
Place:
Institution:
Date: 2025
Language: en
This study examines transport Social Impact Assessment (SIA) practices in various-sized cities in England, addressing a gap in the research that typically focuses on megacities. Given that SIA is a relatively new planning tool in many countries, this research draws on England’s advanced and robust SIA frameworks, which offer clear guidelines and systematic methodologies. The study reviews 90 transport planning and appraisal documents from 15 Local Authority Districts and includes interviews with transport practitioners. It finds that the Transport Analysis Guidance (TAG) issued by the Department for Transport is central to SIA practices in England, ensuring consistency and comprehensiveness. The SIA process is structured in multiple stages, emphasizing public participation and stakeholder engagement to ensure transparency and inclusivity. The focus on equity and inclusivity is strengthened through the use of Equality Impact Assessments, aimed at mitigating negative impacts on vulnerable groups. The systematic approach combines both quantitative and qualitative data, guided by TAG’s indicator selection. However, the study also highlights key limitations, such as TAG’s insufficient coverage of social issues, lack of standardized methodologies at the local level, and limited funding and resources. Further, inconsistencies between national, regional, and local priorities and superficial public participation are identified. The paper suggests ways to address these shortcomings and stresses the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration. The findings from the English case study provide insights that can help other cities develop context-specific SIA frameworks suited to their socio-economic conditions.