Social Impact Assessment in Practice: What Would Make It Work Better?
Resource Key: FCQCSKAF
Document Type: Report
Creator:
Creators Name:
Place: Australia
Institution: Insight into Impact
Date: 2026
Language: en
This report analyses 22 responses to “Social Impact Assessment in Practice: What Would Make It Work Better?,” a survey distributed on LinkedIn between 19 August and 1 September 2026 via SurveyMonkey. The survey is a direct follow-on from the 7 July 2026 Tuesday Dialogues session hosted by The Brisbane Dialogues, exploring Social Impact Assessment (SIA) from three points of view: the project view (companies and consultants), the people-in-place view (affected communities), and the regulator view (government and decision-makers). The purpose of this report is twofold: to stand alone as a piece of research, and to sharpen the agenda for a forthcoming Brisbane event bringing social impact assessment practitioners, project proponents, regulators and community and Indigenous representatives into the same room. The headline finding is that trust in the SIA process is genuinely split: the average sits at 3.0 out of 5, but this average hides a real divide. Twenty-seven percent of respondents report low trust and 32% report high trust, with the largest single group (41%) sitting in the middle. That divide tracks a respondent’s position in the process: those closer to delivering SIA (company and project teams and practitioners, 12 of 22 respondents) report meaningfully higher trust on average than the community and public respondents in this sample. This is a pattern, not proof, given how small some of the underlying groups are. However, it is consistent with what came out of the 7 July session, and this survey extends it in a specific, useful way (Section 2). The single most trust-damaging concern in this data is the independence of who pays for and conducts an assessment. It shows up as a leading answer in two separate questions, and respondents whose top concern is this funding relationship report the lowest average trust of any concern group. A second, less obvious finding is that “being consulted earlier” and “having real influence over outcomes” are experienced as two different things by respondents: wanting real influence tracks with low trust, while wanting earlier involvement does not. Finally, no respondent in this survey identified as a regulator, yet project and practitioner respondents are the only ones who said they specifically want to hear a regulator’s answer to these questions. That is a genuine gap in this evidence, and an argument, from the data itself, for why the event needs a real regulator voice in the room.